Volume 16, Issue 2 (5-2025)
Res Anim Prod 2025, 16(2): 104-114 |
Back to browse issues page
Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
Tajik khari M, Peykani Machiani G, Salehi A, Gholizadeh M. (2025). Estimation of Parameters of the Growth Models of Holstein Calves Using the DOLS Method and Comparing it with Some Non-Linear Models. Res Anim Prod. 16(2), 104-114. doi:10.61882/rap.2024.1471
URL: http://rap.sanru.ac.ir/article-1-1471-en.html
URL: http://rap.sanru.ac.ir/article-1-1471-en.html
1- Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Animal and Fisheries Sciences, University of Agricultural and Natural Resources of Sari, Sari, Iran
2- Department of Economic Science, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
3- Department of Animal and Poultry Science, Faculty of Agricultural Technology, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
2- Department of Economic Science, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
3- Department of Animal and Poultry Science, Faculty of Agricultural Technology, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
Abstract: (601 Views)
Extended Abstract
Background: The study of growth is a key economic aspect of domestic animal breeding, as adult cattle weight is an important trait in breeding programs due to its impact on economic factors, such as maintenance requirements, reproduction, and other biological characteristics.
There are extensive mathematical models, including logistic, Gompertz, Von Bertalanffy, Brody, and Richards, which are used to express the growth capacity and statistical relationships between the age and weight of the animal.
This study focuses on mathematical models that summarize growth patterns using biologically interpretable parameters. These models provide valuable insights for developing breeding strategies by allowing for adjustments in management practices and genetic structures related to growth curves. As a result, analyzing growth curves serves as a foundation for adapting breeding policies, determining nutritional requirements, and making informed decisions about specific technologies. In the growth curve, the A parameter represents the weight at maturity—essentially, the maximum weight of the animal. The B parameter indicates the time at which the individual reaches its maximum growth rate, while the K parameter reflects the growth rate at maturity. Regression coefficients and growth parameters play a critical role in management and breeding decisions, as these parameters typically exhibit good heritability and can be effectively used for the genetic improvement of dairy calves. In this study, we explore the growth pattern of Holstein calves using the dynamic nonlinear model (DOLS) for the first time. We compare its effectiveness with other nonlinear models, such as Gompertz and Logistic.
Methods: For this study, we utilized birth weight and body weight records from 10 to 90 days of age collected at the Kohan Aberdej Agriculture and Industry Unit in Tehran Province. We recorded approximately 10 body weight measurements for each weanling calf, which were initially analyzed using Excel 2007 software. Subsequently, we performed statistical analyses using non-linear Gompertz and logistic models from the nlme statistical package in R software. The nlme package in R is used to fit and compare Gaussian linear and nonlinear mixed-effects models. It allows users to specify variance-covariance structures, enabling the analysis of data with hierarchical or correlated structures. To estimate growth parameters, we employed numerical calculations and the Gauss-Newton algorithm. In the DOLS method, a nonlinear method based on the law of diminishing returns is used to estimate the parameters of the growth model, which correctly estimates the regression coefficients of the growth stages. We evaluated the goodness of fit of the models based on the corrected coefficient of determination (R_Adj^2) and mean square error (MSE).
Results: Both the logistic and DOLS models provide the best description of the growth pattern. These models exhibit high values of R_Adj^2 and the lowest MSE. While the logistic model has demonstrated strong performance in estimating growth parameters for dairy calves in previous studies, it does have a weakness: it tends to overestimate or underestimate body weight at different time points. However, the DOLS model, as demonstrated in this study, accurately predicts body weights at various times without such biases. This is a key strength of the DOLS model. Various models have been introduced in studies to predict maturity weight and maturity rate, with differences often attributed to factors such as breed, management practices, and feeding methods. Notably, the Gompertz model ranked last among the non-linear models. Evaluation indicators confirm that the DOLS model excels, with a high R_Adj^2 value and low MSE. Furthermore, it effectively calibrates time and body weight at turning points, ensuring accurate predictions within the available field data. Here is a corrected and more clearly structured version of your sentence.
In the DOLS model, a concave curve is generated based on the law of diminishing returns, allowing infinite time to be approximated by the time available in real data. This model produces a well-defined function that is differentiable, enabling accurate prediction of the maximum mature weight using the first-order derivative. Additionally, the DOLS method estimates the final weight in the shortest possible time and, unlike the logistic and Gompertz models, does not require iterative procedures, such as the Gauss-Newton algorithm.
Conclusion: The results showed that, unlike Gompertz and logistic nonlinear models, the DOLS growth model exhibits dynamics in the estimation of growth model parameters. Additionally, while logistic and Gompertz models do not allow for achieving the maximum economic productivity using food inputs, the DOLS model effectively establishes a relationship between the amount of consumed inputs and maximum productivity. Consequently, this model can be employed to provide expert recommendations. By differentiating the DOLS model, it is possible to accurately predict the maturity weight and estimate the optimal time for marketing and selling calves. Because the DOLS growth model provides accurate predictions of maturity weight, it can be incorporated into management plans to help improve economic productivity.
Background: The study of growth is a key economic aspect of domestic animal breeding, as adult cattle weight is an important trait in breeding programs due to its impact on economic factors, such as maintenance requirements, reproduction, and other biological characteristics.
There are extensive mathematical models, including logistic, Gompertz, Von Bertalanffy, Brody, and Richards, which are used to express the growth capacity and statistical relationships between the age and weight of the animal.
This study focuses on mathematical models that summarize growth patterns using biologically interpretable parameters. These models provide valuable insights for developing breeding strategies by allowing for adjustments in management practices and genetic structures related to growth curves. As a result, analyzing growth curves serves as a foundation for adapting breeding policies, determining nutritional requirements, and making informed decisions about specific technologies. In the growth curve, the A parameter represents the weight at maturity—essentially, the maximum weight of the animal. The B parameter indicates the time at which the individual reaches its maximum growth rate, while the K parameter reflects the growth rate at maturity. Regression coefficients and growth parameters play a critical role in management and breeding decisions, as these parameters typically exhibit good heritability and can be effectively used for the genetic improvement of dairy calves. In this study, we explore the growth pattern of Holstein calves using the dynamic nonlinear model (DOLS) for the first time. We compare its effectiveness with other nonlinear models, such as Gompertz and Logistic.
Methods: For this study, we utilized birth weight and body weight records from 10 to 90 days of age collected at the Kohan Aberdej Agriculture and Industry Unit in Tehran Province. We recorded approximately 10 body weight measurements for each weanling calf, which were initially analyzed using Excel 2007 software. Subsequently, we performed statistical analyses using non-linear Gompertz and logistic models from the nlme statistical package in R software. The nlme package in R is used to fit and compare Gaussian linear and nonlinear mixed-effects models. It allows users to specify variance-covariance structures, enabling the analysis of data with hierarchical or correlated structures. To estimate growth parameters, we employed numerical calculations and the Gauss-Newton algorithm. In the DOLS method, a nonlinear method based on the law of diminishing returns is used to estimate the parameters of the growth model, which correctly estimates the regression coefficients of the growth stages. We evaluated the goodness of fit of the models based on the corrected coefficient of determination (R_Adj^2) and mean square error (MSE).
Results: Both the logistic and DOLS models provide the best description of the growth pattern. These models exhibit high values of R_Adj^2 and the lowest MSE. While the logistic model has demonstrated strong performance in estimating growth parameters for dairy calves in previous studies, it does have a weakness: it tends to overestimate or underestimate body weight at different time points. However, the DOLS model, as demonstrated in this study, accurately predicts body weights at various times without such biases. This is a key strength of the DOLS model. Various models have been introduced in studies to predict maturity weight and maturity rate, with differences often attributed to factors such as breed, management practices, and feeding methods. Notably, the Gompertz model ranked last among the non-linear models. Evaluation indicators confirm that the DOLS model excels, with a high R_Adj^2 value and low MSE. Furthermore, it effectively calibrates time and body weight at turning points, ensuring accurate predictions within the available field data. Here is a corrected and more clearly structured version of your sentence.
In the DOLS model, a concave curve is generated based on the law of diminishing returns, allowing infinite time to be approximated by the time available in real data. This model produces a well-defined function that is differentiable, enabling accurate prediction of the maximum mature weight using the first-order derivative. Additionally, the DOLS method estimates the final weight in the shortest possible time and, unlike the logistic and Gompertz models, does not require iterative procedures, such as the Gauss-Newton algorithm.
Conclusion: The results showed that, unlike Gompertz and logistic nonlinear models, the DOLS growth model exhibits dynamics in the estimation of growth model parameters. Additionally, while logistic and Gompertz models do not allow for achieving the maximum economic productivity using food inputs, the DOLS model effectively establishes a relationship between the amount of consumed inputs and maximum productivity. Consequently, this model can be employed to provide expert recommendations. By differentiating the DOLS model, it is possible to accurately predict the maturity weight and estimate the optimal time for marketing and selling calves. Because the DOLS growth model provides accurate predictions of maturity weight, it can be incorporated into management plans to help improve economic productivity.
Keywords: Calibration, Goodness of Fit Model, Growth parameters, Law of diminishing returns, Turning point
Type of Study: Research |
Subject:
ژنتیک و اصلاح نژاد دام
Received: 2024/05/22 | Accepted: 2024/12/23
Received: 2024/05/22 | Accepted: 2024/12/23
Send email to the article author
| Rights and permissions | |
 |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
