Volume 15, Issue 4 (12-2024)
Res Anim Prod 2024, 15(4): 129-144 |
Back to browse issues page
Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
Rashid Sanchuli Z, Hosseini-Yekani S, Kashiri Kolaei F. (2024). Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Dairy Cow Breeding Units through Ration Management with Emphasis on the Life Cycle Assessment Approach. Res Anim Prod. 15(4), 129-144. doi:10.61186/rap.15.4.129
URL: http://rap.sanru.ac.ir/article-1-1205-en.html
URL: http://rap.sanru.ac.ir/article-1-1205-en.html
1- Department of Agricultural Economics, Sari Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources University, Sari, Iran
2- Leibniz Centre for Agricultural Landscape Research (ZALF), Muncheberg, Germany
2- Leibniz Centre for Agricultural Landscape Research (ZALF), Muncheberg, Germany
Abstract: (883 Views)
Extended Abstract
Background: Global warming and the role of greenhouse gases in its creation are among the important topics investigated in many domestic and foreign studies. Livestock activities are among the factors that cause these gases. Therefore, to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases, necessary measures should be taken in livestock units. In this regard, in the present study, the optimal ration of dairy cows was determined with an emphasis on reducing greenhouse gas emissions in the form of a life cycle assessment. For this, the optimal ration was first determined with the economic goal of reducing costs, and then the ration was determined aiming at reducing greenhouse gas emissions in different scenarios of cost increase (5-25%) compared to the optimal economic state. To determine the optimal ration in this research, Holstein dairy cows with a weight of 600 kg and an average production of 30 kg of milk per day were considered in one of the large dairy cattle breeding units in Mazandaran province. In the present study, the amount of greenhouse gas emissions caused by animal feed was calculated in the form of the life cycle, the effects of both not burning plant residues and reducing the use of chemical fertilizers were investigated on the amount of greenhouse gas emissions in dairy cattle breeding units.
Methods: The required data were collected from the sample dairy cattle breeding unit, the Agricultural Jihad of Mazandaran Province, the FAO website, the NRC book, and some other information sources. The used model includes the ration cost minimization model and the greenhouse gas emission minimization model in the form of life cycle assessment. GAMS software was used to calculate the results.
Results: The results indicate that to minimize the cost of providing ration, sugar beet pulp at an amount of 15.83 kg per day is replaced by materials such as corn silage, wheat bran, wheat straw, and barley constitute the most part, respectively, with values of 7.91, 7.91, and 7.72 kg per day. On the other hand, it is necessary to limit the consumption of corn, fish meal, and soybean meal in the diet. The emission of greenhouse gases in this case is about 41.19 kg eq CO2. The total cost is also equal to 396,480 Rials, which is reduced by 26% compared to the basic state. The results of determining the optimal ration aiming at reducing greenhouse gas emissions indicate that sugar beet pulp, corn silage, wheat bran, and wheat straw with values of 15. 67, 9.17, 7.84, and 7.84 kg per day, respectively, have the highest share in the scenario of a 5% increase in ration costs obtained in the previous method. In this situation, greenhouse gas emissions will decrease to a greater extent (around 7.7%) with a 5% increase in ration costs. If the cost of the total ration is increased by 25%, the emission of greenhouse gases will decrease by 25.68%. In this case, the largest portion of the ration will be sugar beet pulp, corn silage, and wheat bran with the values of 15.66, 15.71, and 6.37 kg per day, respectively. Overall, based on the results, materials such as corn silage, sugar beet pulp, and wheat bran have a higher share than the other materials by reducing greenhouse gas emissions in different cost scenarios. Soybean and cornmeal are also among the ingredients that are reduced in the diet to further reduce greenhouse gases. Based on the results obtained in all scenarios of cost increase, methane from rumen fermentation, energy consumption, manure management, and then soil management respectively have the most contribution to greenhouse gas emissions. Examining other scenarios of this research also indicates that not burning plant residues, which is now approved as a government policy, reduces the amount of greenhouse gas emissions caused by soil management and thus the total amount of greenhouse gas emissions by 0.61%.
Conclusion: Based on the results of this research, the equivalent amount of CO2 emitted per kg of milk decreases by assuming more costs. Greenhouse gas emissions of about 1.21 and 1.003 kg eq of CO2 per kg of milk are obtained in the scenarios of a 5%-25% increase in costs. The results of this research have shown that to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in different cost scenarios, it is better for materials such as sugar beet pulp, corn silage, and wheat bran to have a higher share than the other materials. Increasing the share of these materials aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, which seems to be an effective step in reducing pollution by encouraging the consumption of these materials. The results of the trade-off between the cost of ration and the amount of greenhouse gas emissions in all the investigated scenarios indicate that the percentage of reductions in greenhouse gas emissions was higher than the percentage of increases in ration costs. In general, it can be concluded that the use of conventional models of ration determination, which are based on the minimization of ration cost, and not paying attention to the reduction of environmental consequences such as the emission of greenhouse gases, leads to the selection of unsuitable rations from the environmental point of view. According to the results of the research, it is possible to take appropriate measures, such as subsidizing the consumption of materials that emit less greenhouse gases, as well as charging a fine for consuming materials that increase greenhouse gas emissions and a fine for burning plant residues, to improve the environment.
Background: Global warming and the role of greenhouse gases in its creation are among the important topics investigated in many domestic and foreign studies. Livestock activities are among the factors that cause these gases. Therefore, to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases, necessary measures should be taken in livestock units. In this regard, in the present study, the optimal ration of dairy cows was determined with an emphasis on reducing greenhouse gas emissions in the form of a life cycle assessment. For this, the optimal ration was first determined with the economic goal of reducing costs, and then the ration was determined aiming at reducing greenhouse gas emissions in different scenarios of cost increase (5-25%) compared to the optimal economic state. To determine the optimal ration in this research, Holstein dairy cows with a weight of 600 kg and an average production of 30 kg of milk per day were considered in one of the large dairy cattle breeding units in Mazandaran province. In the present study, the amount of greenhouse gas emissions caused by animal feed was calculated in the form of the life cycle, the effects of both not burning plant residues and reducing the use of chemical fertilizers were investigated on the amount of greenhouse gas emissions in dairy cattle breeding units.
Methods: The required data were collected from the sample dairy cattle breeding unit, the Agricultural Jihad of Mazandaran Province, the FAO website, the NRC book, and some other information sources. The used model includes the ration cost minimization model and the greenhouse gas emission minimization model in the form of life cycle assessment. GAMS software was used to calculate the results.
Results: The results indicate that to minimize the cost of providing ration, sugar beet pulp at an amount of 15.83 kg per day is replaced by materials such as corn silage, wheat bran, wheat straw, and barley constitute the most part, respectively, with values of 7.91, 7.91, and 7.72 kg per day. On the other hand, it is necessary to limit the consumption of corn, fish meal, and soybean meal in the diet. The emission of greenhouse gases in this case is about 41.19 kg eq CO2. The total cost is also equal to 396,480 Rials, which is reduced by 26% compared to the basic state. The results of determining the optimal ration aiming at reducing greenhouse gas emissions indicate that sugar beet pulp, corn silage, wheat bran, and wheat straw with values of 15. 67, 9.17, 7.84, and 7.84 kg per day, respectively, have the highest share in the scenario of a 5% increase in ration costs obtained in the previous method. In this situation, greenhouse gas emissions will decrease to a greater extent (around 7.7%) with a 5% increase in ration costs. If the cost of the total ration is increased by 25%, the emission of greenhouse gases will decrease by 25.68%. In this case, the largest portion of the ration will be sugar beet pulp, corn silage, and wheat bran with the values of 15.66, 15.71, and 6.37 kg per day, respectively. Overall, based on the results, materials such as corn silage, sugar beet pulp, and wheat bran have a higher share than the other materials by reducing greenhouse gas emissions in different cost scenarios. Soybean and cornmeal are also among the ingredients that are reduced in the diet to further reduce greenhouse gases. Based on the results obtained in all scenarios of cost increase, methane from rumen fermentation, energy consumption, manure management, and then soil management respectively have the most contribution to greenhouse gas emissions. Examining other scenarios of this research also indicates that not burning plant residues, which is now approved as a government policy, reduces the amount of greenhouse gas emissions caused by soil management and thus the total amount of greenhouse gas emissions by 0.61%.
Conclusion: Based on the results of this research, the equivalent amount of CO2 emitted per kg of milk decreases by assuming more costs. Greenhouse gas emissions of about 1.21 and 1.003 kg eq of CO2 per kg of milk are obtained in the scenarios of a 5%-25% increase in costs. The results of this research have shown that to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in different cost scenarios, it is better for materials such as sugar beet pulp, corn silage, and wheat bran to have a higher share than the other materials. Increasing the share of these materials aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, which seems to be an effective step in reducing pollution by encouraging the consumption of these materials. The results of the trade-off between the cost of ration and the amount of greenhouse gas emissions in all the investigated scenarios indicate that the percentage of reductions in greenhouse gas emissions was higher than the percentage of increases in ration costs. In general, it can be concluded that the use of conventional models of ration determination, which are based on the minimization of ration cost, and not paying attention to the reduction of environmental consequences such as the emission of greenhouse gases, leads to the selection of unsuitable rations from the environmental point of view. According to the results of the research, it is possible to take appropriate measures, such as subsidizing the consumption of materials that emit less greenhouse gases, as well as charging a fine for consuming materials that increase greenhouse gas emissions and a fine for burning plant residues, to improve the environment.
Type of Study: Research |
Subject:
مدیریت دامپروری و تولید
Received: 2024/04/5 | Accepted: 2024/07/30
Received: 2024/04/5 | Accepted: 2024/07/30
Send email to the article author
| Rights and permissions | |
 |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
